Pros and Cons of Reroofing vs Full Replacement | Skokie Smart Roofing

When your roof starts showing signs of wear or storm damage, one big decision looms: Should you reroof, or invest in a full roof replacement?

At Skokie Smart Roofing, we’ve guided hundreds of homeowners through this exact choice.

This post lays out the pros and cons of reroofing vs full replacement Skokie Smart Roofing customers ask about—so you can make the best decision for your home in Illinois.

Understanding Reroofing vs Full Replacement: Skokie Smart Roofing Insights

Reroofing involves placing a new layer of shingles over your existing roof, while full replacement means removing everything down to the decking and starting fresh. Here's a breakdown to help you choose.

Pros and Cons of Reroofing vs Full Replacement Skokie Smart Roofing Experts Want You to Know

Reroofing Pros:

• Lower cost upfront

• Faster installation with less disruption

• No tear-off = less waste

• Extends life if current roof is sound

  
  

Reroofing Cons:

• Only possible once (if one layer exists)

• Doesn’t fix hidden structural issues

• Adds weight to roof structure

• May trap moisture

  
  

Full Replacement Pros:

• Replaces damaged decking and underlayment

• New flashing, vents, and water barriers

• Longer warranty

• Adds resale value

  
  

Full Replacement Cons:

• Higher initial investment

• Takes longer

• Temporary disruption to home routine

  
  

How Skokie Smart Roofing Helps You Decide

Every roof is different. That’s why Skokie Smart Roofing offers detailed inspections to assess whether reroofing vs full replacement is best for your situation. We evaluate shingle wear, attic moisture, previous repairs, and roof age before recommending a solution.

Ready to Get Started?

Contact us for a free inspection and let Skokie Smart Roofing guide you through the best path forward—whether you choose reroofing or full roof replacement. Your roof, your budget, your decision—backed by expert advice.